15 Secret Restaurants in Flagstaff You Must Try

When you think of Flagstaff, you might picture stunning mountain views and outdoor adventures, but this charming city is also home to a plethora of secret restaurants that are waiting to be discovered. Tucked away in quaint corners, these hidden culinary gems serve delightful meals that reflect the region’s diverse flavors and culinary creativity. From cozy cafes to intimate dining spots that only locals know about, let us guide you through 15 secret restaurants in Flagstaff that you absolutely must try.

1. The Cottage Place Restaurant

When searching for secret restaurants in Flagstaff, The Cottage Place Restaurant is an absolute gem to discover. Nestled in a charming, historic home, this cozy eatery offers an intimate dining experience that is perfect for any occasion. As you step inside, you’ll be greeted by a warm and inviting atmosphere that feels just like home. The menu features a delightful mix of American classics and innovative seasonal dishes, prepared with fresh, locally-sourced ingredients.

One of the must-try items includes their renowned stuffed French toast, which is simply heavenly. Additionally, their craft cocktails and extensive wine selection will make your dining experience even more enjoyable. Make sure to reserve a table ahead of time as this hidden treasure can fill up quickly!

2. Matruchhaya Indian Cuisine

Matruchhaya Indian Cuisine is another hidden jewel among the secret restaurants in Flagstaff. Known for serving authentic Indian dishes, this restaurant welcomes guests with a vibrant atmosphere and friendly service. The menu boasts a wide selection of vegetarian and non-vegetarian options, catering to all tastes.

For an enticing fan-favorite, try the butter chicken paired with garlic naan. The flavors are rich and guaranteed to leave your taste buds dancing. Moreover, the lunch buffet allows you to sample a variety of dishes at an excellent price, making it perfect for newcomers to Indian cuisine.

3. La Fonda Salvadorena

If you seek a taste of El Salvador, La Fonda Salvadorena is the place to go. This hidden gem is among the top secret restaurants in Flagstaff, offering delicious and authentic Salvadoran cuisine. The casual setting and friendly staff create a welcoming ambiance for all visitors.

Be sure to order the pupusas, which are thick corn tortillas stuffed with various fillings such as cheese, beans, and pork. The unique flavors and comforting textures will have you coming back for more. Additionally, their fresh homemade salsa adds an extra layer of deliciousness.

4. Pizzicletta

When it comes to discovering secret restaurants in Flagstaff, Pizzicletta should top your list. This quaint eatery is a hidden gem tucked away in downtown. Renowned for its artisanal pizzas, Pizzicletta offers a unique twist on traditional Italian fare. First, you’ll notice the wood-fired oven nestled within, filling the air with a delightful aroma that beckons you in.

As you browse the menu, you’ll find pizza options that highlight fresh, local ingredients. Notably, their Margherita pizza is a crowd favorite, celebrating simple yet exquisite flavors. In addition, their seasonal specials often feature locally-sourced produce, providing an ever-evolving menu.

“A slice from Pizzicletta is not just a meal; it’s an experience that transports you to Italy.”

Ensure you pair your pizza with a delightful selection of craft beers. The ambiance is cozy, making it perfect for a relaxed evening with friends or a romantic date night. However, be ready to arrive early; this spot can get busy, especially on weekends!

5. The Flagstaff Brewing Company

Next on the list of secret restaurants in Flagstaff is The Flagstaff Brewing Company. This brewery-restaurant hybrid is a haven for beer enthusiasts and food lovers alike. With a menu that changes frequently, offering a range of pub-style dishes, you’re bound to find something that satisfies your cravings.

As you enter, you’re greeted by the unmistakable aroma of brewing hops. The warm decor adds to the inviting atmosphere, making it a great spot to unwind after exploring the area. Signature dishes like the Flagstaff burger or the buffalo wings are incredibly popular. However, the real treasure lies in their exceptional craft beers brewed right on-site.

During your visit, be sure to sample their rotating selection of drafts. Not only will you find great food, but the friendly staff can guide you to the perfect pairing for your meal.

“Every visit feels like a celebration at The Flagstaff Brewing Company; it’s where community and flavor come together.”

This lively spot is ideal for gathering with friends, and sharing stories over great bites and brews. Don’t miss out; it’s a staple in Flagstaff’s vibrant dining scene!

6. The Sweet Shoppe

No guide to secret restaurants in Flagstaff would be complete without mentioning The Sweet Shoppe. This charming dessert café is a must-visit for anyone with a sweet tooth. Known for its homemade treats, it truly feels like a slice of heaven for dessert lovers.

Step inside, and you’ll be greeted by an array of colorful cakes, pastries, and gelato. Whether you crave a slice of rich chocolate cake or a refreshing scoop of sorbet, there’s something exquisite for everyone. It’s an ideal spot for a midday treat or to celebrate a special occasion.

Notably, the bakery prides itself on using high-quality ingredients, ensuring that every bite tastes delightful. The atmosphere is cozy and cheerful, making it a wonderful place to relax with a good book or catch up with friends.

“A visit to The Sweet Shoppe transforms any day into a celebration of sweetness.”

Make sure to stop by this little haven; it’s perfect for indulging your sweet cravings while exploring the charming streets of Flagstaff.

7. Brix Restaurant & Wine Bar

In Flagstaff, one of the secret restaurants that should be on your radar is Brix Restaurant & Wine Bar. Tucked away in a charming corner, this spot offers a unique blend of local ingredients and culinary creativity. Just step inside, and you’ll be welcomed by an inviting atmosphere paired with a stylish decor that sets the stage for a memorable dining experience.

The menu is seasonal, with dishes that change to reflect the best that local farms have to offer. For instance, their artisanal cheese selection and fresh meats are perfectly complemented by hand-picked wines. Whether you opt for a satisfying steak or a vibrant vegetarian dish, each plate is artfully crafted with flavors that will leave you wanting more.

Additionally, Brix has an impressive outdoor patio where guests can enjoy their meals al fresco, especially during the warm summer months. So, if you’re looking to experience a mix of gourmet dining and exceptional service, Brix is a top choice for both locals and visitors alike.

Don’t miss out on their wine pairing events, where you can explore unique pairings that complement your meal perfectly!

8. Salsa Brava

If you’re craving something with a bit of heat, Salsa Brava is the go-to among Flagstaff’s secret restaurants. This lively establishment serves up robust Mexican flavors in a casual and friendly setting. The moment you walk in, the vibrant colors and lively ambiance transport you straight to a fiesta.

Salsa Brava is known for its homemade sauces and fresh ingredients. You can choose from a tantalizing selection of tacos, enchiladas, and tamales that cater to all taste buds. Their extensive salsa bar is a crowd favorite, offering a range of spicy to mild options that perfectly suit your preference.

Don’t forget to try their margaritas which are made with freshly squeezed lime juice. With a lively atmosphere and delicious food, Salsa Brava is a must-visit for anyone looking to spice up their dining experience in Flagstaff.

Pro tip: Visit during happy hour for great deals on drinks and appetizers!

9. Diablo Burger

For those who appreciate good food, Diablo Burger is a hidden gem among Flagstaff’s secret restaurants. This restaurant takes the traditional burger experience to a whole new level. The focus here is on local, grass-fed beef, and they pride themselves on crafting the juiciest burgers using high-quality ingredients sourced from nearby farms.

What sets Diablo Burger apart is the unique menu, featuring one-of-a-kind burgers like the “Diablo” which adds a fiery twist with jalapeños and spicy aioli. Guests also have the option to build their own burger from a variety of toppings that are sure to satisfy any craving.

The casual vibe and rustic decor create a welcoming environment, perfect for lunch or dinner. Plus, the outdoor seating allows you to relax and enjoy Flagstaff’s beautiful weather while indulging in mouthwatering bites. For burger enthusiasts, dining at Diablo Burger is an unmissable experience during your visit.

Be sure to pair your burger with their hand-cut fries, which are simply irresistible!

10. The Place Restaurant

The Place Restaurant is a hidden gem nestled in the heart of Flagstaff. It’s often overlooked, yet it offers an exquisite dining experience that you won’t soon forget. With its cozy atmosphere and warm decor, it’s the perfect spot for a romantic dinner or a gathering with friends. Located just off the main strip, The Place Restaurant specializes in hearty dishes made from locally sourced ingredients, making it a fantastic choice for those who appreciate fresh, high-quality food.

One of their standout offerings is the seasonal menu, which changes regularly to showcase Flagstaff’s vibrant culinary culture. Don’t miss their famous house-made pasta, which is simply divine. Additionally, the staff is incredibly friendly and knowledgeable about the menu, making sure that your dining experience is top-notch.

When you’re searching for secret restaurants in Flagstaff, The Place Restaurant is a must-visit. Its unpretentious charm and delicious meals make it memorable.

So, if you find yourself wandering around Flagstaff, make a point to stop by. Whether it’s lunch or dinner, you’ll be welcomed with open arms and leave with a satisfied palate.

11. Mary’s Cafe

Mary’s Cafe is another spectacular addition to the list of secret restaurants in Flagstaff. Tucked away, this cozy eatery is known for its friendly service and homey atmosphere. It’s the kind of place where you’ll feel like family as soon as you walk through the door. Their menu features a delightful mix of comforting American classics and unique specialties.

Breakfast is particularly popular here, with items like fluffy pancakes and savory omelets that will fuel your day. You can typically find locals enjoying their morning coffee and chatting with the staff – it truly is a community spot. And if you’re looking for something lighter, try their salads, which are fresh and vibrant.

Mary’s Cafe is not just a meal; it’s an experience that celebrates the local culture of Flagstaff.

All in all, whether you’re a local or just visiting, you should definitely check out Mary’s Cafe for a meal that feels like home.

12. Beaver Street Brewery

If you’re on the hunt for secret restaurants in Flagstaff, Beaver Street Brewery should be on your radar. This lively brewery combines a love for craft beer with a menu that’s sure to impress. Opened in a historic building, the brewery’s atmosphere is inviting and casual, perfect for a laid-back evening.

One of the highlights of Beaver Street Brewery is their extensive beer selection, which changes based on the season. Pairing their unique brews with tasty pub fare makes for a remarkable experience. Their wood-fired pizzas are a crowd favorite and shouldn’t be missed! Each bite combines a delightful crunch with the freshest toppings.

Beaver Street Brewery isn’t just a place to grab a drink; it’s a culinary experience where great flavor and craft beer meet.

So, gather your friends and enjoy a night of good food, great company, and fun craft beers – Beaver Street Brewery won’t disappoint!

13. The Bagel Place

When it comes to discovering secret restaurants in Flagstaff, The Bagel Place truly stands out. This quaint eatery is more than just a bagel shop; it’s a cozy hub where locals gather for their daily dose of deliciousness. As you step inside, the delightful aroma of freshly baked bagels greets you, hinting at the treats waiting to be devoured.

Offering an array of bagels, spreads, and toppings, this restaurant caters to both classic and adventurous palates. You can choose from the traditional plain or opt for a unique flavor like everything or jalapeño cheddar. Additionally, their homemade cream cheese spreads are a must-try!

Don’t miss out on their special breakfast sandwiches; they’re perfect for a quick bite before exploring the scenic wonders of Flagstaff.

Furthermore, enjoy your meal alongside a cup of fresh coffee or a refreshing juice. The friendly staff takes pride in making you feel at home, ensuring you have a wonderful dining experience. Make sure to stop by The Bagel Place on your next visit to savor a hidden gem in the heart of Flagstaff!

14. Rustic Table

Nestled in a charming corner of Flagstaff, Rustic Table is another secret restaurant in Flagstaff you don’t want to overlook. This eatery captures the essence of farm-to-table dining, emphasizing fresh, local ingredients prepared with love. Upon entering, you’ll notice its warm atmosphere, which feels like a cozy cabin retreat.

The menu here is seasonal, ensuring that every dish bursts with flavor. Guests rave about the creative salads, hearty soups, and mouthwatering entrees. You MUST try their signature Rustic Burger—it’s a favorite among regulars!

For a memorable experience, consider dining on the patio during the warmer months; the stunning views of the surrounding mountains enhance your meal.

Don’t forget to pair your food with a selection from their tasteful wine list. Overall, Rustic Table is perfect for families, couples, or anyone wanting to enjoy a delightful meal while soaking in the warm, welcoming atmosphere. Set aside some time during your visit to Flagstaff to indulge in this culinary treasure!

15. Pita Jungle

Pita Jungle is an enticing addition to the list of secret restaurants in Flagstaff. This vibrant eatery emphasizes healthy cuisine without sacrificing flavor. With its lively decor and upbeat atmosphere, you’ll instantly feel excited as you explore their menu.

This restaurant is known for its Mediterranean-inspired dishes. From warm pita bread to hearty falafel, each item on the menu promises a burst of flavor. Additionally, their customizable salads allow you to mix and match ingredients according to your taste preferences, making it perfect for the health-conscious traveler.

Pro tip: don’t skip their house-made hummus—it’s simply divine!

Furthermore, Pita Jungle often features local art, creating an inviting environment that encourages diners to relax and enjoy their meal. Their commitment to using quality ingredients and creating a vibrant atmosphere makes Pita Jungle a must-visit when searching for hidden culinary gems in Flagstaff. So, gather your friends and prepare for a feast that marries health and taste perfectly!

Flagstaff’s secret restaurants offer a unique culinary experience that showcases the hidden flavors and local favorites of this vibrant city. From contemporary dining to exotic cuisines, each restaurant tells a story that is worth exploring. Have you dined at any of these secret spots or know of others that should be added to the list? Share your discoveries in the comments, and get ready for a delicious culinary journey in Flagstaff!