20 Secret Dining Spots in Santa Cruz You Must Try

Secret dining spots in Santa Cruz offer food lovers a chance to explore the unique culinary scene away from the typical tourist traps. This coastal city is not only known for its stunning beaches and vibrant boardwalk, but also for its hidden gems where you can enjoy delicious meals in charming atmospheres. From tiny taco stands with secret family recipes to cozy basement bistros that feel like a home away from home, the food scene here is bursting with flavor and creativity. Join us as we unveil 20 secret dining spots in Santa Cruz that promise to elevate your dining experience.

1. The Penny Ice Creamery

If you are looking for secret dining spots in Santa Cruz, The Penny Ice Creamery is a must-visit. Nestled in the heart of downtown, this ice cream shop is not just about dessert; it offers a delightful experience for all ages. Their handcrafted ice creams and sorbets are made using organic, locally-sourced ingredients, ensuring each bite is fresh. You can try flavors like lavender honey or salted caramel, which have become local favorites.

Moreover, the cozy ambiance of the shop invites you to linger. You can easily enjoy your scoop while watching the hustle of the city. Hence, visiting here is not only a treat for your taste buds but also a chance to soak in the lively atmosphere of Santa Cruz.

Don’t miss out on their seasonal flavors, which rotate regularly and add a unique touch to your visit!

As day turns to evening, this peaceful spot transforms into a local treasure. The Penny Ice Creamery certainly adds a sweet end to your dining journey.

2. Cafe Gratitude

Cafe Gratitude is another gem among the secret dining spots in Santa Cruz. Dedicated to healthy, wholesome food, this vegan café serves dishes that are as nourishing as they are delicious. Their menu is entirely plant-based and features seasonal ingredients sourced from local farmers.

One of the charming aspects of this café is its unique naming system. Each dish is named with an affirmation, such as “I am Thriving” or “I am Grateful,” inviting diners to reflect on positivity. Furthermore, the atmosphere here is welcoming and relaxed, making it a perfect place to reconnect with friends or simply enjoy a peaceful meal alone.

As you savor your meal, you will appreciate not just the flavors but also the ethos of sustainability that guides the restaurant.

Whether you are a long-time vegan or simply curious, Cafe Gratitude provides a nourishing and refreshing pause in your Santa Cruz adventure.

3. The Crow’s Nest

When searching for secret dining spots in Santa Cruz, don’t overlook The Crow’s Nest. This picturesque waterfront restaurant offers stunning views of the ocean and the iconic Santa Cruz Wharf. Known for their seafood, their menu features fresh catches from the coast, including local specialties like clam chowder and fish tacos.

What makes The Crow’s Nest special is its inviting atmosphere. With both indoor and outdoor seating, you can soak in the sunset as you enjoy your meal. You may even spot surfers riding the waves in the distance! It’s a peaceful retreat from the busyness of the boardwalk.

The happy hour at The Crow’s Nest is a local favorite, where you can savor discounted small plates and drinks as the sun sets.

Indeed, this venue offers a delightful mix of great food, breathtaking views, and a laid-back vibe that captures the essence of what dining in Santa Cruz is all about.

4. Shadowbrook Restaurant

One of the true secret dining spots in Santa Cruz is the stunning Shadowbrook Restaurant. Nestled in a lush canyon, this restaurant offers a charming experience that feels like a hidden treasure. To reach the entrance, you can either walk down a scenic path or take a unique cable car ride down the hillside. This adds to the allure, making it feel like an exclusive getaway.

Dining at Shadowbrook means enjoying delicious food in a serene and picturesque setting. Their menu presents a variety of seasonal dishes made from fresh, local ingredients. Moreover, the restaurant is renowned for its stunning views of the creek and the surrounding nature. As you savor your meal, you might even spot some wildlife, which enhances the overall dining experience.

Be sure to try their famous Rainbow Trout or the decadent Lobster Ravioli—both are crowd favorites!

Whether it’s a romantic dinner or a special celebration, the ambiance at Shadowbrook Restaurant is perfectly suited for any occasion. With its enchanting surroundings and exceptional cuisine, it’s no wonder that many consider it one of the best secret dining spots in Santa Cruz.

5. Gabriella Cafe

Next on the list of secret dining spots in Santa Cruz is Gabriella Cafe, a cozy and inviting eatery located in the vibrant downtown area. This hidden gem focuses on farm-to-table dining, featuring an ever-changing menu based on what local farmers provide each season. As a result, freshness is always at the forefront of their culinary creations.

The atmosphere at Gabriella Cafe is warm and welcoming, with rustic decor and ample natural light streaming through the large windows. This venue provides a perfect ambiance for enjoying a meal with friends or family. Their popular dishes include hand-crafted pastas and artisanal pizzas that are simply scrumptious.

A great tip is to pair your meal with one of their unique, locally sourced wines for a complete dining experience.

So, if you are searching for a place that captures the essence of Santa Cruz’s local flavors, Gabriella Cafe is an under-the-radar spot you won’t want to miss!

6. The Gourmet Deli

Finally, let’s uncover The Gourmet Deli, another fantastic entry on the list of secret dining spots in Santa Cruz. Tucked away in a charming neighborhood, this deli specializes in delectable sandwiches, salads, and house-made soups. If you’re looking for a quick yet mouthwatering meal, The Gourmet Deli is a place you should definitely consider.

What makes this deli unique is its commitment to using fresh, high-quality ingredients. The sandwiches are crafted with love and offer an array of interesting flavors that cater to all taste preferences. Everything is made to order, ensuring that each dish is as delightful as the last.

Their signature “Deli Box” is a must-try—it’s a perfect choice if you want a taste of everything!

In a city where casual dining can often feel generic, The Gourmet Deli stands out as a local favorite where the staff is friendly and the flavors are bold. With its cozy atmosphere and delicious offerings, this deli is indeed one of Santa Cruz’s secret culinary treasures.

7. Zoccoli’s Delicatessen

When it comes to secret dining spots in Santa Cruz, Zoccoli’s Delicatessen is a hidden gem that both locals and visitors adore. Nestled amidst the bustling streets, this delicatessen combines an authentic deli experience with a vibrant atmosphere. As you enter, the aroma of freshly baked bread and gourmet ingredients welcomes you.

The menu features a variety of delicious sandwiches, made with high-quality meats and local produce. Additionally, there are vegetarian options available, ensuring there’s something for everyone. It’s worth noting that Zoccoli’s is also known for its fabulous breakfast selections, perfect for those early risers.

Moreover, the charming decor, complete with art from local artists, provides a unique dining experience. Sit inside or opt for outdoor seating to enjoy the beautiful California weather. Whether you’re a local or just passing through, don’t miss out on this delightful spot!

8. d’aprile

Another fantastic option among the secret dining spots in Santa Cruz is d’aprile. This cozy eatery is a delightful place for those seeking a unique dining experience. It features a seasonal menu crafted from fresh, locally-sourced ingredients that celebrate California cuisine. As you step inside, you’ll instantly feel a warm and inviting ambiance.

Each dish at d’aprile is carefully prepared, ensuring full flavors with every bite. For a truly memorable experience, try their chef’s specials that change regularly. Furthermore, they offer a superb selection of wines to pair with your meal. If you’re planning a dinner with friends or a romantic night out, d’aprile provides both incredible food and a charming setting.

Don’t forget to save room for dessert – their sweet offerings are sure to satisfy any sweet tooth!

9. The Watsonville Farmers Market

For food lovers, the Watsonville Farmers Market is one of the best secret dining spots in Santa Cruz that showcases local flavors and artisanal products. Held weekly, this market is not just a shopping destination, but also a fantastic place to grab a quick bite. With an array of vendors offering fresh produce, homemade goods, and ready-to-eat meals, every visit is a delightful culinary adventure.

As you browse through the stalls, sample artisan cheeses, fresh fruits, or gourmet street food. It’s a great way to experience the local community while savoring delightful flavors. Additionally, the market often hosts local musicians, creating a lively atmosphere that enhances your dining experience.

The Watsonville Farmers Market is perfect for those looking to enjoy fresh and vibrant local cuisine while supporting local farmers and artisans. Make sure to check the market schedule to catch this delicious experience!

10. Charcuterie & Co.

If you are on the hunt for secret dining spots in Santa Cruz, Charcuterie & Co. is a delightful treasure. This unique spot specializes in artisanal charcuterie boards, combining local meats, cheeses, and gourmet accompaniments. As you step inside, you’ll instantly be struck by the cozy ambiance, perfect for a relaxing meal.

Their board selections vary by season, so there’s always something new to try. Pair your tasteful platter with a glass of local wine or craft beer for an added touch. Not only is the food exceptional, but the staff is friendly and knowledgeable, making your experience even better.

Don’t miss their specials—they often feature locally sourced ingredients, supporting sustainable practices.

Whether you choose to dine in or grab a picnic to-go, Charcuterie & Co. is a must-visit for anyone looking to savor the flavors of Santa Cruz. This hidden gem promises a flavorful journey through the area’s rich culinary scene.

11. Oswald Restaurant

For those seeking an upscale dining experience among secret dining spots in Santa Cruz, Oswald Restaurant is the perfect choice. Tucked away in a stylish setting, Oswald offers an eclectic menu that showcases fresh, local ingredients. From the moment you enter, you’re greeted by an inviting atmosphere that prepares you for a memorable meal.

Each dish is crafted with skill and care, making use of seasonal produce. You might find yourself enjoying a delectable seafood dish or a hearty meat entrée that bursts with flavor. Their extensive wine list complements the menu beautifully, so don’t hesitate to ask for recommendations!

Oswald is ideal for special occasions or when you simply want to indulge in amazing dining.

The intimate setting and impeccable service create an unforgettable dining experience. Plan your visit early, as this hidden gem tends to be popular among locals and savvy tourists alike.

12. The Dairy Shop

The Dairy Shop is another hidden gem for a casual yet delicious meal among the secret dining spots in Santa Cruz. This quaint eatery specializes in comfort food with a twist, showcasing locally sourced dairy products. The rustic feel of the shop adds to its charm, making it a cozy place to grab a bite or simply enjoy a sweet treat.

From gourmet grilled cheeses to creative desserts, The Dairy Shop offers something delicious for everyone. Make sure to try their house-made ice cream; it’s a favorite among locals and a fantastic way to cool down on warm days.

It’s definitely a great place to relax, especially after exploring the nearby beaches.

The Dairy Shop not only serves up tasty food but also embodies the spirit of community supported by its use of local ingredients. A visit here will leave you satisfied and wanting to return for more of their delightful offerings.

13. The Avenue Cafe

The Avenue Cafe is a charming spot perfect for anyone searching for secret dining spots in Santa Cruz. Tucked away in a bustling neighborhood, this quaint cafe specializes in breakfast and brunch options. The atmosphere is inviting, with local artwork adorning the walls, creating a community vibe that makes every visitor feel welcome.

When it comes to the menu, prepare for delightful surprises. You simply can’t miss their signature avocado toast, which is a crowd favorite. Additionally, their homemade pastries are fresh and irresistible. As you sip your coffee, take in the performances by local musicians, which often take place on weekends, adding to the warm ambiance.

Be sure to check out their daily specials, as they often highlight seasonal ingredients sourced from local farms!

Visiting during weekdays means fewer crowds, allowing for a more leisurely dining experience. Whether you’re solo or with friends, The Avenue Cafe is a hidden gem waiting to serve you.

14. The Secret Garden Cafe

As the name suggests, The Secret Garden Cafe creates a serene atmosphere that transports you away from the hustle and bustle of Santa Cruz. Nestled within a garden, this cafe offers a picturesque setting to enjoy fresh, seasonal dishes. The lush greenery and blooming flowers provide a calming backdrop for your dining adventure.

This spot is particularly known for its incredible brunch menu. From granola bowls to delicious quiches, every dish is made thoughtfully with love. Furthermore, their hand-crafted juices are a refreshing treat that pairs perfectly with any meal.

Don’t forget to explore the garden after your meal; it’s a perfect spot for a post-lunch stroll!

The Secret Garden Cafe is ideal for those looking for a peaceful getaway while enjoying delightful cuisine. It’s not just a meal here, but an entire experience – one that is memorable and uniquely Santa Cruz.

15. La Posta

La Posta is another secret dining spot in Santa Cruz that will entice your taste buds. With an air of authentic flair, this restaurant combines delicious food with a cozy atmosphere. La Posta specializes in Mexican cuisine, offering traditional dishes that make you feel as if you’ve been transported to Mexico itself.

One of their standout offerings is the huevos rancheros, served with homemade salsa that adds a burst of flavor to your meal. Additionally, their freshly made tortillas are something you simply have to try. Each bite leaves you craving more!

For a truly unique experience, visit for dinner and enjoy their tacos paired with an extensive list of local wines!

La Posta’s friendly staff and vibrant decor make it a delightful place to enjoy a leisurely meal with friends or family. Just be sure to go early, as this hidden gem can get quite busy, especially during weekends!

16. Tacos Moreno

If you’re searching for secret dining spots in Santa Cruz, Tacos Moreno is an absolute gem. Tucked away from the bustling tourist spots, this taco joint offers authentic Mexican street food that’s sure to delight your taste buds. You’ll find it located off the beaten path, yet the inviting aroma of grilled tortillas and sizzling meats beckons you to enter.

This cozy eatery is known for its delectable tacos, made fresh daily with high-quality ingredients. The menu features a variety of options including carne asada, al pastor, and vegetarian choices. Moreover, the prices are wallet-friendly, making it perfect for casual dining or a quick bite on the go.

Don’t miss the chance to try their secret salsa – it’s a crowd favorite that brings a unique twist to their dishes!

Whether you’re a local or just visiting, Tacos Moreno guarantees a warm atmosphere and friendly service. Grab a taco, sit outdoors, and enjoy a moment of relaxation in this hidden treasure of Santa Cruz.

17. The Hideout

The Hideout is a fantastic choice when you explore secret dining spots in Santa Cruz. This restaurant truly lives up to its name, offering a chill atmosphere that feels like a private escape. The rustic interior and intimate seating make it an ideal spot for a romantic dinner or a quiet gathering with friends.

The menu is diverse, featuring comfort food with a gourmet twist. From hearty burgers to fresh salads, The Hideout focuses on using seasonal ingredients sourced from local farms. Plus, their craft cocktails and extensive wine list ensure you’ll find the perfect drink to complement your meal.

For a special treat, be sure to check out their daily specials; they’re creative and often highlight local produce!