20 Secret Bars in Key West You Must Discover

Key West is renowned for its lively nightlife, but beyond the popular tourist spots, there are hidden gems waiting to be discovered—secret bars that exude charm, creativity, and a true taste of local culture. Whether you’re seeking a cocktail infused with tropical flair, a cozy nook with a laid-back vibe, or a speakeasy tucked away from the bustling streets, these secret bars in Key West promise an unforgettable experience. Join us as we uncover 20 of the best-kept secrets that will take your night out in Key West to the next level.

1. The Green Parrot

If you’re searching for secret bars in Key West, The Green Parrot is a must-visit destination. Nestled off the main drag, this lively bar presents a laid-back vibe that keeps both locals and tourists returning. The moment you step inside, you’ll feel transported back in time. The walls are adorned with local memorabilia, adding to its unique charm.

At The Green Parrot, enjoy live music almost every night of the week. The lively atmosphere enhances the experience, making it perfect for a relaxed evening out. Moreover, don’t forget to sample their extensive drink menu; their cocktails are both refreshing and intriguing!

After grabbing a drink, take a moment to step outside onto their spacious patio. Here, you can unwind while enjoying the Key West breeze. If you’re there during sunset, it’s an unbeatable view! So, make The Green Parrot your first stop when exploring the secret bars in Key West.

2. Blind Pig

Another gem on your quest for secret bars in Key West is the Blind Pig. This hidden speakeasy is tucked away behind an unassuming entrance. A subtle sign will guide you, but keep an eye out because this place is easy to overlook!

Once inside, you’ll discover an intimate setting with dim lighting and artistic decor. The ambiance sets the perfect backdrop for a cozy evening with friends or even a romantic date. The bartenders here are skilled mixologists, so you can trust them to craft the perfect cocktail just for you!

In addition to their amazing drinks, Blind Pig often hosts themed nights and live entertainment. You might find everything from acoustic performances to trivia nights. Overall, this bar captures the essence of Key West while still maintaining an air of secrecy.

3. Santiago’s Bodega

Santiago’s Bodega is more than just a typical bar; it’s a vibrant spot that’s among the top secret bars in Key West. This tapas restaurant offers a fantastic selection of small plates and an impressive wine list. While dining here, indulge in their numerous drink options, including specialty cocktails that are simply divine.

The atmosphere is colorful and inviting, making it an ideal location to enjoy a night out with friends or to relax after a day of exploring. What’s more, the staff is known for their friendly service, adding a personal touch to your experience.

Every Wednesday, they host a fun wine tasting event, making it a perfect mid-week escape. Overall, Santiago’s Bodega combines fine dining with a bar atmosphere you won’t want to miss. When exploring secret bars in Key West, be sure to add this delightful spot to your list!

4. The Rum Bar

When you mention secret bars in Key West, The Rum Bar immediately springs to mind. Nestled within the vibrant atmosphere of the island, this hidden gem is a must-visit for any enthusiast of rum. With over 150 varieties to choose from, you’ll be spoilt for choice while sipping from their handcrafted cocktails or sampling local rums.

The Rum Bar isn’t just about the drinks; it’s about the experience. The cozy ambiance, coupled with the warm, friendly staff, ensures a welcoming atmosphere for both locals and visitors. As you relax and unwind, you might even strike up a conversation with fellow rum lovers sharing their favorite cocktails.

“Explore different rum flavors and discover the passionate culture surrounding this beloved spirit.”

Another highlight is their regular rum tasting events. Here, you can delve deeper into the world of rum, learning about different brands and distillation methods. So, be sure to find time in your itinerary to visit The Rum Bar—it promises an unforgettable night filled with rich flavors and lively conversations.

5. The Speakeasy Inn

The Speakeasy Inn offers a unique trip back in time, showcasing a classic vibe of the Prohibition era. This secret bar in Key West radiates history with its vintage decor and cozy atmosphere. The moment you step inside, you’ll feel as though you’ve entered another world.

Known for its expertly crafted cocktails, The Speakeasy Inn features a menu that pays homage to classic drinks from the past. Their mixologists are skilled and passionate, ensuring every sip tells a story. Not to mention, the laid-back outdoor seating area provides a perfect spot to enjoy your drink while basking in the tropical breeze.

“For an authentic experience, try one of their specialty cocktails inspired by the 1920s!”

In addition, the Speakeasy Inn often hosts live music, creating an entertaining backdrop to your evening. Make sure to visit this hidden treasure; it beautifully embodies the spirit of Key West’s nightlife.

6. The Old Town Tavern

The Old Town Tavern is yet another hidden delight among the secret bars in Key West. This charming spot is popular among locals and travelers alike. Its unpretentious vibe makes it a great place to relax with friends or meet new ones. The warm hospitality here, combined with a casual atmosphere, reflects the true essence of island life.

While at The Old Town Tavern, take the opportunity to enjoy local craft beers or classic cocktails. Their happy hour specials attract a crowd, encouraging an environment of camaraderie where stories are shared, and laughter fills the air. Furthermore, the menu offers delicious bar bites that pair perfectly with your drink of choice.

“Don’t miss the chance to engage with locals and hear captivating tales about Key West!”

The Old Town Tavern also provides live music and events, enhancing your experience as you indulge in the lively culture of Key West. Remember to include this tavern in your list of secret bars to explore!

7. The Whiskey Obsession Festival Bar

If you’re a fan of whiskey, then the Whiskey Obsession Festival Bar in Key West is a hidden gem you won’t want to miss. This unique bar is renowned for its extensive selection of whiskeys from around the world, making it an ideal destination for enthusiasts looking to expand their palate.

Each event at the festival features a lineup of high-end whiskeys and a chance to interact with distillers. Moreover, it’s not just about tasting; the knowledgeable staff are ready to provide insights and recommendations, ensuring you have a memorable experience. You’ll find it located amidst the bustling atmosphere of Old Town, yet it still offers the serene vibe of a secret bar.

For a truly immersive experience, be sure to attend during the festival season when exclusive whiskey tastings and events take place!

In addition to whiskey, the bar also serves delicious cocktails and mouthwatering small bites. Don’t hesitate to explore this noteworthy venue and find out why it stands out among the secret bars in Key West.

8. The Bottoms Up Bar

The Bottoms Up Bar isn’t just any regular bar, but a favorite amongst locals and an exciting stop for visitors. Nestled away from the touristy spots, it offers an intimate atmosphere where you can unwind after a busy day of exploring.

This bar is particularly popular for its friendly service and daily drink specials, making it an affordable choice for those seeking fun. You’ll likely find the bar buzzing with laughter and conversation, which gives it an inviting and cozy vibe. Whether you’re a local or a traveler, it quickly feels like home.

Insider tip: The Bottoms Up Bar is known for its creative cocktails, so don’t miss out on trying one!

Furthermore, this charming spot often features live music, turning an ordinary evening into an unforgettable night. If secret bars in Key West excite you, make sure to add The Bottoms Up Bar to your list!

9. Captain Tony’s Saloon

No visit to Key West is complete without a stop at Captain Tony’s Saloon. This iconic bar is steeped in history, and it’s a must-see for anyone looking for a genuine island experience. Originally a bait and tackle shop, it has evolved into one of the most beloved haunts in the area.

What sets Captain Tony’s apart is its vibrant atmosphere, filled with memorabilia, tales of rum runners, and ghost stories. The bar often hosts local musicians, allowing patrons to enjoy live performances while sipping on colorful cocktails. And, if you’re lucky enough, you might catch a famous visitor who made this bar their own.

For a memorable evening, try the signature drinks, which reflect the lively spirit of Key West.

This saloon isn’t just about drinks; it embodies the culture and history of the island. So grab a seat at the bar, and immerse yourself in the lore of the famous Captain Tony’s!

10. Little Room Jazz Club

The Little Room Jazz Club is a hidden gem in Key West that embodies the true spirit of live music and vibrant nightlife. Nestled away from the bustling streets, this intimate venue offers a cozy atmosphere for jazz lovers and night owls alike. The ambiance is inviting, with dim lighting and comfortable seating, allowing you to relax and enjoy the rhythm of the night.

As you enter, you’ll be greeted by the soulful sounds of local jazz musicians. The schedule is packed with talented artists, making any night a memorable one. This venue is perfect for those looking to savor a drink while listening to smooth tunes. In fact, the club often features special drink menus that complement the musical experience.

For an authentic evening, consider arriving early to snag a good seat and indulge in their specialty cocktails.

Little Room Jazz Club also hosts open mic nights and jam sessions, inviting you to experience the local music scene up close. Plus, the friendly staff is always there to suggest a cocktail or two that perfectly matches your mood. When searching for secret bars in Key West, this spot is a must-visit for both music enthusiasts and casual bar-goers.

11. The Sloppy Joe’s Bar

No visit to Key West would be complete without a stop at the legendary Sloppy Joe’s Bar. This iconic venue has a rich history, dating back to the 1930s when it became a favorite haunt of expatriate author Ernest Hemingway. Known for its lively atmosphere and colorful decor, Sloppy Joe’s is a hub for both locals and tourists, making it a must-visit spot.

Not only does this bar serve up tasty drinks, but it also features live music throughout the week. From rock bands to solo acoustic artists, there’s always something happening here. Moreover, complete your experience by trying their signature Sloppy Joe sandwich, which is as famous as the bar itself.

Don’t miss the chance to dive into the history of this bar while sipping on a refreshing cocktail.

Secret bars in Key West often play tricks on visitors. While Sloppy Joe’s may be more famous, it captures the essence of the playful, laid-back vibe that defines the island. Be sure to stop by for a cold drink, some quality tunes, and a good dose of local culture.

12. Dry Tortugas National Park Bar

While not your typical bar, the Dry Tortugas National Park Bar offers a unique experience for those adventurous enough to venture out to this remote location. Accessible only by ferry or seaplane, this bar is located on the stunning Garden Key, home to the historic Fort Jefferson. The incredible views and tranquil waters set the stage for a memorable outing.

Here, you can enjoy drinks under the sun while marveling at the picturesque scenery. Although the selection is limited, the atmosphere makes up for it. Sip on a cold beer or a fruity cocktail while watching dolphins play in the distance or seagulls soar overhead.

For the best experience, be sure to pack sunscreen and stay hydrated!

Even though it might not top the list of traditional secret bars in Key West, this hidden paradise offers a refreshing twist on the standard bar experience. Relax, connect with nature, and take in the beauty of the Dry Tortugas as you unwind at this unique destination.

13. The Oyster Bar

When you’re in search of secret bars in Key West, The Oyster Bar is an inviting hidden gem. Tucked away in the heart of Old Town, this bar is renowned for its relaxed atmosphere. The moment you step inside, you’ll be enveloped by the warmth and charm of a true Keys experience.

The Oyster Bar offers a wide selection of wines and craft cocktails, making it an ideal spot to unwind after a day of exploring. One highlight is their fresh seafood offerings, which pair perfectly with a refreshing drink. Furthermore, happy hours here feel like a celebration among friends.

What’s more, the bar’s intimate setting is perfect for friendly conversations or even a romantic evening. As you sip your drink, take a moment to soak in the local art that adorns the walls. Consequently, The Oyster Bar not only serves great drinks and food but also nurtures a vibrant community spirit.

Don’t miss their oysters—considered some of the best in town!

In conclusion, if you’re looking to blend delicious eats with great drinks, The Oyster Bar deserves a spot on your Key West itinerary.

14. Besame Mucho

Another captivating choice when seeking secret bars in Key West is Besame Mucho. This bar effortlessly combines a lively ambiance with a sense of exclusivity. With its unique decor and cozy corners, it’s an inviting place to discover the rich flavors of craft cocktails inspired by Latin culture.

Once you walk through the door, you’ll be greeted by professional bartenders ready to concoct something special just for you. Their margaritas and mojitos are particularly noteworthy. Furthermore, the live music often fills the air with a joyful energy, drawing in patrons and creating a friendly atmosphere. As a result, it’s a perfect spot to dance or simply enjoy the vibrant night.

The attention to detail in both the drinks and the ambiance makes Besame Mucho an unforgettable part of your Key West journey. Also, the exquisite tapas menu complements the drink selection splendidly. When seeking a lively yet intimate spot, you can’t go wrong here.

The flavorful drinks at Besame Mucho are a party in a glass!

Don’t miss the opportunity to enjoy this unique fusion of culinary and drinking experiences in Key West.

15. Mangoes Restaurant & Bar

Mangoes Restaurant & Bar is a delightful inclusion on the list of secret bars in Key West. Located close to the bustling Duval Street, this bar offers a unique blend of a lively atmosphere and tropical flair that is quintessentially Key West. The vibrant decor and outdoor seating area invite you to relax and enjoy your surroundings

The bar prides itself on offering a wide variety of refreshing cocktails and flavorsome dishes that highlight local ingredients. From delicious seafood to pizza, the menu caters to diverse tastes, making it a favorite among locals and visitors alike. Moreover, the friendly staff adds to the welcoming vibe.

Live music often fills the air, creating a joyful atmosphere that encourages guests to mingle. As the day turns into night, Mangoes transforms into a lively social hub, where you can unwind and meet new friends. Consequently, this bar is not just about drinks; it’s about creating cherished memories.

Don’t forget to try their signature Mango Mojito, a refreshing tropical treat!

In summary, Mangoes Restaurant & Bar is a must-visit for anyone looking to experience the authentic charm of Key West while indulging in great food and drinks.

16. The Porch

When you think of secret bars in Key West, don’t overlook The Porch. This hidden gem combines a cozy atmosphere with an extensive drink menu crafted from local ingredients. Nestled amidst the busy streets, it’s a favorite among locals and visitors alike. The Porch offers not just drinks but a unique experience where you can unwind and enjoy the relaxed vibes Key West is known for.

As you step inside, the ambiance wraps around you like a warm breeze. Soft lighting combined with a laid-back crowd makes the perfect setting for a quiet night out. Whether you’re a cocktail aficionado or simply in love with the local craft beers, The Porch has something to satisfy every palate.

Additionally, feel free to strike up a conversation with the bartenders. They are not only knowledgeable about their drinks but can also offer great insights into other secret spots around the city. Thus, make sure to add this to your list of must-visit places while enjoying the nightlife in Key West.

17. Wasabi’s Sushi Bar

If you’re craving something different, Wasabi’s Sushi Bar is a top choice among the secret bars in Key West. This bar and restaurant combines a love for sushi with an extensive drink menu, specializing in unique cocktails that perfectly complement their culinary offerings. It’s nestled in a quiet part of the island, making it a perfect spot to enjoy some quality time away from the crowds.

What sets Wasabi’s apart is its vibrant decor. The colorful artwork and inviting seating create an energetic atmosphere ideal for mingling. On top of that, the sushi rolls are not only delicious but artistically crafted. Pair them with one of their specialty drinks for an unforgettable dining experience!

Don’t miss the chance to try their signature cocktails, as they perfectly capture the essence of Key West!

Overall, Wasabi’s Sushi Bar is more than just a place to eat; it’s a memorable spot to unwind and indulge in the local food scene.

18. The Blue Room

Located away from the mainstream hustle, The Blue Room is one of those secret bars in Key West that doesn’t flaunt itself. Instead, it invites you in with an air of mystery and charm. Once you step inside, you’ll be greeted by deep blue walls and soft lighting that create a serene ambiance, perfect for a quiet drink after a long day in the sun.

The Blue Room focuses on providing quality craft cocktails, and each drink is prepared with care. You can take your pick from a wide selection ranging from classics to innovative creations. Plus, the intimate setting makes it an ideal spot for both couples and solo visitors wanting to unwind.

Interestingly, live music often fills the air, enhancing the experience further. Local artists showcasing their talent offers a dynamic and vibrant atmosphere that truly captures Key West’s spirit. So, whether you’re a local or a traveler, The Blue Room is a must-visit during your Key West adventures.

19. The 801 Bourbon Bar

The 801 Bourbon Bar stands as a beacon for lovers of vibrant nightlife, nestled in the heart of Key West. Known for its lively atmosphere, this bar is a must-visit when exploring the secret bars in Key West. As soon as you step inside, you’ll be greeted with a mix of locals and tourists, all seeking to unwind and enjoy great company.

This bar has a unique story, having transformed from a humble establishment to a renowned hotspot. While visiting, don’t miss the chance to try one of their signature cocktails. The bartenders are skilled and can whip up a delightful drink that tickles your taste buds!

Moreover, the 801 Bourbon Bar often features live entertainment, ranging from drag shows to local music performances. This makes it a perfect place to soak in the vibrant culture of Key West. So, if you’re looking for somewhere to enjoy a night out and make new friends, this is the place to be.

“The 801 Bourbon Bar perfectly captures the fun spirit of Key West nightlife!”

20. El Meson de Pepe

Nestled amidst the hustle and bustle of Key West is El Meson de Pepe, a hidden gem that boasts a unique blend of Cuban and Caribbean ambiance. When searching for secret bars in Key West, this spot is often overlooked, yet it’s truly a treasure worth seeking out.

As you enter, the colorful decor and lively music immediately transport you to a different world, filled with warmth and hospitality. The bar serves a delightful array of authentic Cuban cocktails, made with fresh ingredients, ensuring every sip is a celebration.

Besides drinks, the culinary offerings are equally impressive. Don’t miss out on their delicious tapas, perfect for sharing with friends. The atmosphere at El Meson de Pepe embodies the essence of Key West – vibrant, welcoming, and full of life.

“To truly experience the flavors of Key West, El Meson de Pepe is a must-visit bar!”

Key West boasts an amazing array of secret bars, each offering a unique atmosphere and exceptional cocktails. These hidden spots provide a perfect opportunity to mingle with locals, enjoy live music, and experience the vibrant energy of the island. Have you stumbled upon any secret bars in Key West? Share your discoveries in the comments, and be sure to plan a visit to one of these gems on your next night out!